James Nicoll Reviews

Home > Reviews > By Date

Reviews from October 2025 (23)

Been Through the Desert

M. F. K., volume 1

By Nilah Magruder  

31 Oct, 2025

Doing the WFC's Homework

3 comments

2025’s 2017’s M. F. K. Volume 1 is the first volume of Nilah Magruder’s M. F. K. secondary-universe middle-grade fantasy graphic novel.

(I don’t know why I thought this was a new release)

The Confederacy does not inflict heavy-handed nanny-stating on a minor desert town like Little Marigold. Little Marigold is free to eke out what meagre living it can, for as long as it can.

Strangers visiting Little Marigold are nothing new. However, few arrive, badly wounded, staggering out of a sandstorm with a dying moa.

Abbie is one of those strangers.

Read more ➤

These Three Words

The Fairy of Ku-She

By M. Lucie Chin  

30 Oct, 2025

Big Hair, Big Guns!

3 comments

M. Lucie Chin’s 1988 The Fairy of Ku-She is a stand-alone historical fantasy. It is set in Ming Dynasty China.

The Fairy of Ku-She (Ku-She for short) is the guardian of the Golden Chopsticks, which in concert with the Crystal Snow-vase apportion snowfall. Although she is but a minor fairy, her duty is an important one. Without snow, there can be no rain. Without rain, no crops.

Therefore, the theft of the Golden Chopsticks is a calamity.


Read more ➤

Always Sweet It Sounds

Touring After the Apocalypse, volume 6

By Sakae Saito  

29 Oct, 2025

Translation

2 comments

2024’s Touring After the Apocalypse, Volume Six is the sixth tankōbon in Sakae Saito’s post-apocalyptic iyashikei manga. Touring has been serialized in in ASCII Media Works’ seinen manga magazine Dengeki Maoh since September 2020. Amanda Haley’s English translation was published in 2025.

Having escaped an exploding volcano and a (sort-of) killer robot in Volume Five, Youko and Airi now ponder why they so relentlessly tour Japan’s ruins1. What dreadful secret compels the pair?

Read more ➤

Fiery Gospel

Days of Atonement

By Walter Jon Williams  

28 Oct, 2025

The Realized World

2 comments

Walter Jon Williams’ 1991 Days of Atonement is a stand-alone, gothic-western, hard-science-fiction police procedural.

Atocha Chief of Police Loren Hawn has a lot on his plate. Atocha, New Mexico is small but diverse. Its people are pious, supporting forty-one different churches. Everyone knows their place or at least the sensible people do. Those who forget can expect a visit from Hawn.

What Atocha needs is a functional economy. What it has is a closed mine. That spells trouble for the town and for Hawn. Hawn could use a distraction.

Distraction comes in the form of a mortally-wounded man.

Read more ➤

Game Never Ends

Death in the Cards

By Mia P. Manansala  

24 Oct, 2025

Doing the WFC's Homework

1 comment

Mia P. Manansala’s 2025 Death in the Cards is a young-adult mystery novel.

High school student Danika Dizon gives her fellow students affordably-priced tarot-card readings. Danika’s card reading for Mary Elizabeth Eli” Delgado provides would-be PI Danika with something novel: her very first detective case.

Eli paid Danika for a reading. Then, Eli vanished.

Read more ➤

First Hello

Girl in the Creek

By Wendy N. Wagner  

23 Oct, 2025

Cosmic Horror!

1 comment

Wendy N. Wagner’s 2025 Girl in the Creek is a stand-alone science fiction horror novel.

Bryan Harper vanished near Faraday, Oregon. After a perfunctory investigation, police concluded that Bryan committed suicide. But Bryan’s sister Erin cannot believe that Bryan killed himself. Furthermore, Erin knows something about Faraday that the police appear to have overlooked or willfully ignored.

Faraday has a missing persons problem.

Read more ➤

No Place To Raise Your Kids

Man Plus  (Man Plus, volume 1)

By Frederik Pohl  

19 Oct, 2025

Because My Tears Are Delicious To You

15 comments

1976’s Man Plus is the first volume in Frederik Pohl’s Man Plus near-future science fiction series.

Astronaut Roger Torraway is just one member of the Man Plus program, which is tasked with establishing a colony on Mars. Since Mars is uninhabitable and transforming Mars is out of the question, Roger’s team has been ordered to transform a human into something that can survive on Mars.

A lot is riding on the project. A successful Mars colony might reverse the US’ declining fortunes. It might also save civilization.


Read more ➤